I've wondered about this too, especially after seeing some veneer installations that looked great initially but didn't age well. Could it be more about the installation method or prep work rather than just the product itself? Maybe proper sealing or drainage behind the veneer makes a bigger difference than we think. Has anyone noticed if certain installation techniques help veneer hold up better outdoors, even in tough climates?
I've seen some veneer jobs done perfectly—proper drainage, sealing, the whole nine yards—and they still didn't hold up great after a few harsh winters. Maybe veneer just isn't cut out for extreme climates, no matter how careful you are with installation?
I've noticed similar issues with veneer in colder climates, even when installed meticulously. You're right—sometimes the material itself just isn't suited for extreme temperature swings and moisture cycles. I've had clients who initially loved the look and cost-effectiveness of veneer, but after a few harsh winters, they ended up regretting not going with solid brick. That said, I wouldn't completely dismiss veneer altogether. In milder climates or protected areas (like covered porches or interior accent walls), it can hold up beautifully and offer significant savings.
Your observations are spot-on though; sometimes it's less about installation quality and more about choosing materials that naturally align with your local climate conditions. If you're dealing with frequent freeze-thaw cycles, real brick might indeed be worth the extra investment and hassle in the long run.
Has anyone here actually had veneer hold up really well in harsher climates long-term? I'm genuinely curious because my own experience wasn't great. A few years back, I used brick veneer around my garage—thought it looked fantastic, and it seemed like a smart way to save some cash. But after a couple winters with constant freeze-thaw cycles, sections started loosening up, and moisture got behind it. Ended up having to redo the whole thing, and this time I bit the bullet and went with solid brick.
I do agree though, veneer can be perfect in the right setting. A friend of mine used it indoors for a fireplace surround, and it looks amazing with zero issues. Maybe it's just about being selective with where you put it? Or could it be certain brands or types of veneer are more durable than others?
Totally agree that veneer can be tricky outdoors, especially in climates with harsh winters. I've seen it hold up surprisingly well, but usually only when installed meticulously—proper drainage, moisture barriers, and high-quality mortar are key. Indoors, it's almost always a safe bet. Outdoors though... honestly, I'd lean toward solid brick or stone if budget allows. Veneer can save money upfront, but the headaches down the road aren't always worth it.
