Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Mixing materials definitely helps stretch things further, especially if you’re working with leftovers or reclaimed stuff. I’ve found that using brick as a border keeps the wood slices from shifting around too much, plus it looks a bit more “finished.” I get what you mean about pine - tried it once and it got mushy after one winter, even with sealant. Oak and maple seem to last longer, but they’re not always easy to find cheap.

If you’re worried about uneven wear, maybe set the wood slices in gravel or sand instead of straight dirt? That way, if any start to rot or break down, swapping them out isn’t a huge hassle. I’m also curious if anyone’s tried using concrete rounds instead of wood for the same look - might be more work up front, but zero maintenance. Just a thought.


Reply

I get the appeal of concrete rounds, but honestly, I think they lose some of that cozy, organic vibe you get with wood slices. Plus, concrete can crack over time if your ground shifts a lot - had that happen in my last place and it was a pain to fix. I actually like the idea of mixing in some stone or even metal accents for durability without going full-on industrial. Just feels a bit warmer, you know?


Reply

“concrete can crack over time if your ground shifts a lot - had that happen in my last place and it was a pain to fix.”

That’s been my experience too. I put in a concrete path a few years back, and after one winter with a lot of rain, I ended up with hairline cracks everywhere. Not the end of the world, but it definitely lost some of that clean look. I’ve switched to flagstone mixed with gravel since then - less hassle, and it still feels pretty natural. Wood slices look great at first, but where I live, they just don’t hold up to the damp.


Reply

“after one winter with a lot of rain, I ended up with hairline cracks everywhere. Not the end of the world, but it definitely lost some of that clean look.”

Yeah, that’s pretty much what I’m worried about. I keep hearing how concrete is “forever,” but then you see those little cracks show up and it’s like... well, so much for that. I get why people go for flagstone or gravel instead - at least if something shifts, it doesn’t look ruined, just kind of... rustic? Plus, you can move stuff around if you need to.

I thought about those wood slices too (they look awesome on Pinterest), but honestly, with all the rain we get here, I’d probably just end up with a muddy mess and a bunch of rotten wood by spring. Sometimes it feels like there’s no perfect answer - just picking what annoys you least over time. Still, good to know I’m not the only one second-guessing concrete.


Reply

Honestly, I wouldn’t write off concrete just because of a few cracks. Everything moves a bit over time - flagstone shifts too, and gravel can get messy or disappear into the dirt if you’re not careful. If you prep the base right and seal it, concrete holds up better than most options. I’ve had mine for years; yeah, there are some lines here and there, but nothing major. At least you don’t have to weed between stones every spring...


Reply

At least you don’t have to weed between stones every spring...

That’s true, but I’ve found concrete can get pricey, especially if you want it to look decent and not just like a big gray slab. When I redid my patio, I went with compacted gravel and pavers - yeah, there’s some weeding, but it’s way easier to fix a sunken spot or swap out a cracked stone than patching concrete. Plus, if you’re on a budget, you can do it in stages instead of all at once. Just my two cents from trying both...


Reply

“yeah, there’s some weeding, but it’s way easier to fix a sunken spot or swap out a cracked stone than patching concrete.”

- True, but I’ve seen pavers shift a lot if the base isn’t perfect - especially after a wet winter.
- Concrete can be pricey upfront, but if you go with a broom finish and add planters or outdoor rugs, it doesn’t have to look boring.
- Maintenance-wise, sealed concrete is almost zero effort compared to chasing weeds every few weeks.
- If you’re after flexibility though, pavers do win for quick fixes. Just depends how much time you want to spend on upkeep vs. install.


Reply

Honestly, after wrestling with pavers that turned into a wavy mess after one bad storm, I get the appeal of concrete. Still, there’s something satisfying about being able to pop out a cracked stone and fix it in an afternoon. Guess it comes down to how much you like DIY... or hate weeds.


Reply

Digging Up the Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I’ve run into that same paver vs. concrete debate on a few projects, and honestly, it’s never as straightforward as it seems. There’s a lot to be said for the flexibility of pavers - being able to swap out a single stone is a huge plus, especially if you’re the type who notices every little crack or chip. But I’ve also seen so many DIY paver jobs where the base prep was rushed or skipped, and then you get those uneven surfaces after just one season. Did you use a compacted gravel base under yours? I’m always curious how much time people spend on that step, since it makes or breaks the whole thing.

Concrete’s definitely lower maintenance in some ways, but then you’re stuck if it cracks - patches never really blend in, and full replacement is a headache. I had a client who went with stamped concrete thinking it’d be the best of both worlds, but after a couple winters, the freeze-thaw cycles left hairline cracks all over. They regretted not going with pavers just for the repairability.

Weeds are another story... I’ve seen people try polymeric sand between pavers to cut down on them, but it only works if you get the joints packed tight enough. Otherwise, you’re out there every spring with a spray bottle or on your knees pulling them up. Sometimes I wonder if anyone’s actually found a truly weed-proof solution.

Out of curiosity, did you find anything weird when you dug up your yard? Last time I helped a friend redo their patio, we found an old horseshoe and what looked like part of a toy train set buried under the sod. Makes me wonder what else is hiding under all these backyards...


Reply

- Totally agree, there’s no “easy” answer with pavers vs concrete. Both have their headaches.
- I’m always skeptical when people say pavers are “so easy” to fix. Sure, if you’ve got a few extras and the exact same style. Otherwise, good luck matching them after a few years - especially on a budget.
- Concrete’s lower maintenance in theory, but like you said, once it cracks, it’s not just an eyesore - it can be a wallet-drainer too.
- We did the compacted gravel base for our pavers (and yeah, it took way longer than I thought). Not sure I’d trust a shortcut there if you want it to last more than one winter.
- Polymeric sand: mixed results for us. Still ended up pulling weeds in the cracks every spring. If there’s a magic bullet for that, I haven’t found it yet.
- Digging up our yard turned up nothing but rocks and some rusty nails… was hoping for buried treasure or at least something cool for the kids to find. Maybe next time.

Honestly, sounds like you’re doing things right by thinking through all the trade-offs. It’s never as simple as the YouTube videos make it look.


Reply

Polymeric sand: mixed results for us. Still ended up pulling weeds in the cracks every spring. If there’s a magic bullet for that, I haven’t found it yet.

That’s been my experience too - polymeric sand is hyped up, but I still find myself out there with a weeding tool every year. I’ve even tried the “boiling water” trick and it’s just... temporary. Sometimes I wonder if the only real solution is to embrace a little wildness and let some moss or groundcover fill in the gaps.

On the paver vs concrete debate, I lean toward pavers just because you can get creative with patterns and colors, but yeah, matching them later is a pain. I’ve seen people mix in a few contrasting stones when they have to replace one, almost like an intentional design choice. Not everyone’s cup of tea, but it can look cool if you commit to it.

Curious - has anyone tried those newer “eco” pavers that let grass grow through? I keep seeing them pop up in design magazines, but I’m skeptical about how they hold up in real life, especially with kids or pets running around.


Reply

Title: Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I get the appeal of those eco pavers, but honestly, I’ve seen a few installations where the grass just turned patchy or muddy - especially in high-traffic spots. They look great in photos, but maintenance seems like a real commitment. Sometimes I think a well-placed groundcover or even low-growing thyme between regular pavers is less hassle and still softens things up. Matching pavers is a pain, but I do like the idea of making it intentional with a few accent stones... kind of turns a problem into a feature.


Reply

Sometimes I think a well-placed groundcover or even low-growing thyme between regular pavers is less hassle and still softens things up.

Totally agree - creeping thyme or even woolly thyme can handle foot traffic better than most grasses, and the scent is a bonus. Have you tried any of the sedums? They’re pretty tough too, especially in sunny spots. I’ve also seen people mix up paver shapes and sizes on purpose to avoid the headache of matching - kind of leans into that “collected over time” look. Curious if anyone’s had luck with moss in shadier areas, though... seems hit or miss depending on soil and moisture.


Reply

Mixing up paver sizes is a smart move - trying to get everything to line up perfectly just isn’t worth the headache. I’ve seen sedum thrive where almost nothing else works, especially if you’re dealing with brutal sun and not much water. Moss is tricky though. In my experience, unless you’ve got consistently damp shade, it just goes patchy or dies off when things dry out. Honestly, if you want low maintenance, stick to the tough groundcovers and skip the moss drama.


Reply

Mixing paver sizes is honestly a game changer - totally agree there. Trying to get those perfect lines is like chasing unicorns, and who has time for that? But I’ve gotta push back a bit on the moss. Sure, it’s fussy, but when it works, it’s like walking through a fairytale. I had a patch behind my old place, shaded by a massive oak, and it was the softest, greenest thing you’ve ever seen. Of course, the second the sun hit it for more than a week, poof - crispy brown sadness.

Sedum is basically the superhero of groundcovers, though. I swear, you could plant it on a baking sheet and it would still find a way to thrive. But sometimes I wonder if we’re all too quick to write off the “high maintenance” stuff. Isn’t a little drama in the garden worth it for those magical moments? Or maybe I just like making things harder for myself...


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

You’re not wrong about the drama - sometimes that’s exactly what makes a garden memorable. I’ll admit I usually lean toward the “set it and forget it” approach (who has time to baby every square foot?), but every now and then, something high-maintenance just grabs your attention and you can’t help yourself. Moss is one of those things. When it works, it’s pure magic, like stepping into a luxury spa. But then reality hits - brown, patchy, and honestly kind of depressing.

I get where you’re coming from on sedum, too. It’s practically bulletproof, which is why I use it around the pool. No one wants to be fussing with groundcover in July when you could be relaxing with a drink instead. Still, I have to admit, there’s a certain satisfaction in pulling off something tricky. Kind of like owning a classic car - sure, it needs constant attention, but when it’s running right, nothing beats it.

Do you ever feel like the “effort vs. payoff” equation in gardening is just impossible to balance? Sometimes I look at these perfect magazine gardens and wonder who has the patience (or staff) to keep them looking that way. Maybe that’s the point, though - those fleeting moments when everything comes together are what make it all worth it.

Anyway, don’t beat yourself up for chasing a bit of garden drama. If you enjoy the process - even the failures - it’s not really wasted effort. Sometimes the best spaces are the ones with a little personality and imperfection.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

That “effort vs. payoff” thing gets me every time. When we moved in, I was determined to have a perfect lawn. I spent a weekend digging, seeding, watering… and then the weeds just laughed at me. Eventually, I picked one small corner and tried some ferns instead - less pressure, more manageable. Now, I just focus on one project at a time. If it flops, it’s just a patch, not the whole yard. Honestly, the little wins feel way better than chasing perfection everywhere.


Reply

I get the appeal of focusing on small wins, but honestly, I think sometimes we give up on the big picture too soon. I’ve seen people transform entire yards by sticking with it - even if it takes a couple years. Perfection’s overrated, sure, but there’s something satisfying about seeing a whole space come together. Maybe it’s just me, but I’d rather wrestle with the weeds than settle for patchwork. Sometimes the mess is part of the charm, you know?


Reply

I hear you on the big picture - there’s something about seeing a whole design come together that just feels right. I once spent two summers mapping out every inch of my backyard, only to realize the “messy” corner with wild violets was everyone’s favorite spot. Sometimes the plan and the chaos end up working together, weirdly enough.


Reply

Funny how that works, right? You can plan every inch, but nature (and people) always find their own favorite spots. I’ve learned to leave a little room for the unexpected - sometimes the “imperfect” bits end up being the best part.


Reply
Scroll to Top