Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

I tried patching with different materials once (long story, don’t recommend), and those seams were a nightmare.

Funny you mention that—I've seen more patchwork roofs fail than last, especially when people try mixing materials. But here's what I'm wondering: did you look into any of those newer roofing systems, like metal panels or synthetic shingles? Some of them claim longer life and less maintenance, but I'm skeptical if they really hold up better than traditional asphalt. Anyone had luck with those, or is it just marketing hype?