Custom homes discussions and local services.

WHERE DO YOU EVEN START WITH HIRING SOMEONE TO DESIGN YOUR HOUSE?

481 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I totally get where you’re coming from. When I hired someone to design my own place, I actually asked her to sketch out her process on a napkin over coffee - no joke. It wasn’t super detailed, but she did walk me through the big milestones and how she deals with curveballs. That gave me a lot more confidence than just flipping through her portfolio. Honestly, seeing how someone reacts to “what if” scenarios tells you way more about working with them than any glossy photos ever could.


Reply

Honestly, seeing how someone reacts to “what if” scenarios tells you way more about working with them than any glossy photos ever could.

I get what you mean, but I actually lean the other way. For me, a designer’s portfolio is still king. I want to see their taste and attention to detail in finished spaces - sometimes people talk a great game but their work just doesn’t vibe with what I’m after. The process matters, sure, but if the end result isn’t stunning, it’s a no-go for me. Maybe it’s just that I’m super visual...


Reply

The process matters, sure, but if the end result isn’t stunning, it’s a no-go for me.

I see your point about the portfolio being “king” - it’s hard to argue with finished work that speaks for itself. Still, I’ve found that a designer’s ability to handle curveballs can be just as important, especially when site conditions or budgets shift unexpectedly. The best results usually come from someone who not only has a strong visual style but can also adapt when things don’t go as planned. Maybe it’s a balance between the two?


Reply

I’ve definitely seen both sides of this. One time, I worked with a client who loved a designer’s portfolio - super glossy, magazine-worthy stuff - but when the project hit a snag (unexpected plumbing issues), the designer just froze. The end result looked good, but getting there was stressful for everyone. I guess I’d rather have someone who can roll with the punches, even if their style isn’t quite as flashy. Has anyone ever hired someone mainly for their adaptability rather than their “wow” factor?


Reply

WHERE DO YOU EVEN START WITH HIRING SOMEONE TO DESIGN YOUR HOUSE?

I get what you mean about the “wow” factor not always being the most important thing. I once worked with a designer who had a reputation for being super creative - her Instagram was full of jaw-dropping spaces. But when we hit a delay with custom cabinetry, she just kept insisting we wait for her preferred vendor, even though there were decent alternatives. It dragged the whole project out for weeks. In hindsight, I wish I’d gone with someone a bit more flexible, even if their portfolio wasn’t as flashy.

But here’s the thing: sometimes the folks who seem adaptable at first end up compromising too much on quality or style. It’s like, where’s the line between being easygoing and just not having a strong vision? Has anyone found that sweet spot, or is it always a bit of a gamble?


Reply

WHERE DO YOU EVEN START WITH HIRING SOMEONE TO DESIGN YOUR HOUSE?

Man, finding that middle ground is tricky. I’ve seen designers who’ll bend over backwards for any request, but then you end up with a house that feels kinda generic. On the flip side, the “my way or the highway” types can be tough when you hit a snag - like your cabinetry situation. I always tell folks to ask about how they handle delays or changes before signing anything. If they can’t give a straight answer, that’s usually a red flag for me.


Reply

Totally get where you’re coming from. I’ve seen both extremes - designers who say yes to everything and you end up with a Pinterest board come to life, but nothing really “you.” On the other hand, some folks are so rigid it’s like pulling teeth if you want to swap out a faucet. Honestly, asking about how they handle changes is smart. I’d add: see if they actually listen when you talk about your lifestyle or routines. If they’re not picking up on that, it’s usually a sign they’ll miss the mark later.


Reply

Totally agree with this:

see if they actually listen when you talk about your lifestyle or routines.
That was a game-changer for me. A few things I learned:

- If you have kids or pets, mention it early - some designers just don’t get the chaos factor.
- Ask to see examples of their past work, but also ask *why* they made certain choices. If they can’t explain, that’s a red flag.
- Don’t be afraid to push back on stuff that feels off. I almost ended up with open shelving everywhere because it “looked nice,” but I knew I’d hate dusting.

You really want someone who gets how you live, not just what looks good on Instagram.


Reply

You really want someone who gets how you live, not just what looks good on Instagram.

Honestly, that’s the key. I’ve had clients who wanted all-white everything because it “looked clean,” but then they’d mention their toddler and two dogs. I always ask: how do you actually use this space? If a designer isn’t asking about your daily chaos, that’s a red flag for me. Open shelving is a classic example - looks great, but who’s dusting it every week?


Reply

Totally agree about the open shelving - looks cool, but I know I’d never keep up with the dust. When you were picking a designer, did you find it hard to balance what you liked visually with what actually works for your life? I keep second-guessing my choices.


Reply

WHERE DO YOU EVEN START WITH HIRING SOMEONE TO DESIGN YOUR HOUSE?

Man, the open shelving thing gets me every time. I love how it looks in photos, but in real life? I swear, my house is like a dust magnet. I tried it once in my last place and ended up just stacking random mugs and cereal boxes on them because I couldn’t keep up with the “styled” look. It’s one of those Pinterest vs. reality situations.

When I was picking a designer, I definitely got caught up in all the pretty stuff at first. You see these portfolios with these gorgeous, minimal kitchens and think, “Yeah, I want that.” But then you remember you’ve got three kids, a dog, and a partner who leaves coffee mugs everywhere. Suddenly, all that white and glass doesn’t seem so practical.

I second-guessed myself a ton. I’d pick something I liked, then start thinking about how it would actually work day-to-day. Like, do I really want a fancy backsplash if it’s just going to get splattered with spaghetti sauce? Or a giant island if it means less space for the dog bed? It’s tough to balance what looks good with what actually fits your life.

Honestly, I started making a list of “non-negotiables” for how we live - stuff like closed storage, easy-to-clean surfaces, and enough room for everyone to dump their bags when they come in. Then I’d show that to the designer and say, “Make it look nice, but don’t mess with these.” It helped me stop overthinking every little choice.

I guess what I’m saying is, it’s totally normal to second-guess yourself. But at the end of the day, you’re the one living there, not the people on Instagram. If you know you’ll never dust open shelves, skip ‘em. If you need a spot for muddy boots, make sure it’s in the plan. The rest is just details.


Reply

If you know you’ll never dust open shelves, skip ‘em.

That’s the realest advice I’ve seen in this thread. I got sucked into the “designer look” trap too, but then my wallet started crying and I realized I needed to be way more practical. Ended up finding someone who was cool with me saying, “No marble, no open shelves, and yes to IKEA hacks.” Sometimes the best design is just stuff that doesn’t make you crazy (or broke) every day.


Reply

Honestly, I think you nailed it. I spent way too long obsessing over Pinterest kitchens, but when it came down to actually living in the space, all that “open concept” and “statement shelving” stuff just felt like a chore. There’s something weirdly satisfying about knowing your kitchen works for your life, not just for some photoshoot. IKEA hacks are underrated, too - half my house is held together by them and you’d never know unless I told you.


Reply

There’s something weirdly satisfying about knowing your kitchen works for your life, not just for some photoshoot.

Totally get this. I’ve seen so many “dream kitchens” that look amazing in photos but would drive me nuts in real life - open shelving is cute until you’re dusting every week or hunting for a mug. Honestly, the best spaces are the ones that actually fit how you cook, eat, and hang out. IKEA hacks are kind of genius for that, too. Sometimes the most practical stuff ends up looking the best because it just... works.


Reply

Honestly, I think a lot of those “designer” kitchens are made for people who barely cook. I’ve lived with both - one house had this magazine-worthy kitchen with glass-front cabinets and a waterfall island, but it was a nightmare to keep clean and nothing was where I needed it. Ended up hating it after six months.

When we remodeled our current place, I started by making a list of what actually bugged me about my old kitchen. Where did stuff pile up? What did I wish was closer to the stove? That kind of thing. Then, when we talked to designers, I could be really specific about what mattered. Some designers just want to do their “look,” but the good ones will ask how you live and work in the space.

IKEA hacks are underrated, honestly. You can get so much more function for less money if you’re willing to be a little creative. At the end of the day, it’s your kitchen - you’re the one living with it, not some Instagram follower.


Reply

IKEA hacks are underrated, honestly. You can get so much more function for less money if you’re willing to be a little creative. At the end of the day, it’s your kitchen - you’re the one living with it, not some Instagram follower.

Totally agree with this. I always wonder who those fancy kitchens are actually for - definitely not the people who actually cook every day. I’m on a pretty tight budget, so when we started looking at designers, I was really upfront about not wanting to pay for stuff that just looks trendy but doesn’t actually work for how we live. I think that’s the biggest thing: you have to know your priorities before you even start talking to someone.

One thing that helped me was making a “must-have” vs “nice-to-have” list. Like, I *had* to have a pull-out pantry, but I didn’t care about having high-end countertops. I also took photos of the spots in our old kitchen where junk would pile up or things would get in the way, just to show the designer what I meant. Some of them were more interested in making it look good for their portfolio, but the one we ended up working with really listened to what we needed - she even suggested a few IKEA cabinet hacks to save money.

I do think there’s a balance, though. Sometimes the super-budget route ends up costing more in the long run if you have to redo things, so I tried to figure out where it made sense to spend a little extra (like on the stuff that gets used every day). But yeah, I don’t get the obsession with having everything look “magazine perfect.” I’d rather have a kitchen that’s easy to clean and actually works for my family.

Curious if anyone else found it hard to get designers to focus on function first? I felt like I had to push pretty hard to keep things practical.


Reply

I’ve definitely run into that with designers - sometimes it feels like they’re designing for a photoshoot, not real life. I actually had to remind ours that I have two dogs and a toddler, so white cabinets everywhere just wasn’t gonna fly. I think the best ones really listen and ask about your routines, but it’s wild how many just want to push the latest trend. Your idea of taking photos of problem spots is genius, by the way. That’s the kind of thing that makes a space actually work for you, not just look good on Pinterest.


Reply

Honestly, I’ve lost count of how many “award-winning” designers I’ve seen who couldn’t care less about how people actually *live* in their homes. It’s like they’re allergic to the idea that a house is for living, not just for staging. The white-cabinet thing drives me nuts - sure, it looks clean in photos, but one muddy paw print or toddler hand and suddenly you’re scrubbing your life away. It’s like some of these folks have never met a dog.

What really gets me is how sustainability gets tossed aside for whatever’s trending on Instagram. I had a designer try to push me into engineered wood floors that looked great but were basically single-use plastics with a wood veneer. When I mentioned wanting something durable and low-VOC because of my kids (and, yeah, pets), she acted like I’d asked for shag carpeting from the ‘70s. There’s no reason design can’t be both practical and eco-friendly, but you have to push for it.

Taking photos of your “problem spots” is smart - wish I’d thought of that before my last remodel. Even better if you can walk a designer through your daily routine and literally point out where things go sideways (the dog food spills, the backpack drop zone, the spot where everyone dumps their shoes). If they roll their eyes or try to redirect you to what’s “in,” that’s a red flag. The best ones will ask *how* you use your space and actually listen.

One thing I’d add: don’t be afraid to ask tough questions about materials and maintenance. If they can’t tell you how something holds up over years - or if it’s recyclable or non-toxic - they probably haven’t thought it through. A good designer should be able to balance aesthetics with real life and environmental impact. Otherwise, you’re just paying for pretty pictures... which isn’t much help when you’re mopping up muddy footprints every day.


Reply

WHERE DO YOU EVEN START WITH HIRING SOMEONE TO DESIGN YOUR HOUSE?

Couldn’t agree more about the disconnect between “award-winning” and actually livable. I’ve seen too many spaces that look great in a portfolio but fall apart once real life happens - kids, pets, groceries, you name it. Maintenance is huge. If a designer can’t explain how to keep something looking good after five years of daily use, that’s a problem. I always tell people: ask for examples of past projects where the clients had similar needs to yours. If they can’t show you any, that’s telling. And yeah, sustainability shouldn’t be an afterthought - it’s not hard to find durable, low-VOC options these days if someone actually cares to look.


Reply

Honestly, I learned the hard way that “pretty” doesn’t always mean practical. Had a designer once pitch me these open shelves in the kitchen - looked awesome in the renderings, but after six months, all I had was dust and grease on every dish. I’d say, if you’re hiring someone, drag them through a day-in-your-life scenario. If they can’t tell you how their design holds up to muddy boots or a toddler with a marker, they’re probably not the right fit. Fancy awards don’t mop floors.


Reply
Scroll to Top